August 29, 2024

Accurate facts that mislead

nobel-winners-by-birth-year
Reading Time: 2 minutes

I’ve always been fascinated by accurate stats that can be misleading.

For example, Simpson’s Paradox explains why Reggie Miller was more accurate than Larry Bird in both three-point shots and two-point shots, but Bird was more accurate when you combine them.

Or you have the fact that Chick-Fil-A is mathematically the fastest drive-thru restaurant, but they’re also mathematically the slowest, and both stats are accurate (and from the same study).

Annie Duke recently shared a similar idea where people used data to show that we’re all getting dumber. Specifically that starting in 1935, Nobel winners by birth year have been steadily dropping. In this case, though, there isn’t a counter-stat to show the other side, but rather it’s just a misleading interpretation of the data. Here’s the chart:

However, Annie sums it up nicely:

Why is the interpretation that people are getting dumber so unfounded here? Because there is an obvious alternative explanation for this seeming disappearance of people of Nobel-Prize-level intelligence: How old are Nobel Prize winners?

Old.

It’s tricky in today’s world because so many of the stats you see (particularly on places like social media) are completely made up. Therefore, if you find data that is verifiably accurate, you feel like you need to reach the conclusion shared with the data.

Or maybe not.

It’s not always easy to find the truth within the truth, but it’s always worth the effort. I encourage you to check out Annie’s post for more.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts

What happens when someone replies to your newsletter?

Reading Time: 2 minutesEven with AI and and social media and all of the chaos you can find online, I sincerely hope that you’re still sending out value-packed…

Read More

You should be ethical to humans, but not necessarily to giant companies

Reading Time: < 1 minuteIs Google an ethical company? For many years, it was believed that they were (at least to a large extent), but over the last decade…

Read More

Sprout Social is the opposite of Slack

Reading Time: 2 minutesRoughly five years ago I told you about how Slack would proactively give refunds if any of our users didn’t use their service for a…

Read More