I moved away from the Amazon ecosystem for books earlier this year, and it’s been fantastic. I’m super happy about that decision and it’s improved my reading life in virtually every way.
However, there was one little missing piece that initially bothered me, but I’ve come to accept that it’s actually a good thing — the “popular highlights” while I read, which look something like this:

If you use a Kindle, you’ve likely seen highlights in books as you’re reading them. It pre-highlights a given passage because others already highlighted it, so perhaps it’s a good one for you to highlight as well. It’s a neat feature!
In moving away from Kindle, no other solutions can really match that (largely because none of them have the volume of readers that Amazon does). I was a bit bummed by that realization at first, but I think my new solution might be better.
As I mentioned that post about my reading process, I’m now spending quite a bit of time after I finish book by going through my notes and really building up a good summary for myself. My highlights now work two ways:
- I read the book and make my highlights along the way.
- As I’m post-processing those highlights, I look up the book on GoodReads and check out some of the most popular highlights on there.
It works well. I can highlight what matters to me, with no distractions, but then I can use GoodReads to show me the popular ones that I might have missed. It’s a good mix of the systems, and allows me to stay deep in my reading but not lose the community thoughts on what’s worth noting.
How do you manage your highlights and notes?


