January 27, 2026

“Link in comments” continues to die

rand-fishkin
Reading Time: 2 minutes

Over the past few years, the value of links in social media posts has plummeted. It’s not that the links themselves have becomes less valuable, but that posts including links are pushed so far down the algorithm that you’re better off not including them. Some data suggests that you’ll get 10x more engagement if you don’t include a link, which is wise but also very problematic.

The solution has been to include a phrase such as “link in comments” in your post, and then follow up the post with a comment that includes the link. I’ve long thought that social media companies would catch onto that little trick, and indeed they have.

Rand Fishkin recently put out a great “5 Minute Whiteboard” video about this problem (which you should absolutely watch), and he offered two suggestions to help.

First, consider skipping the link entirely. He shares an example where they talked about a product, people knew where to find the product, they offered no link to the product, but tons of people went and found it anyhow. The lack of a link hurt a bit, but they got way more engagement and came out better in the long run.

Second, if you’re going to include a link in the comments you should be more subtle about it. Don’t say things like “link in comments” in the post, and when you add the link in the comments you should provide good content around the link to give that individual comment some value on its own. Even better, have others include the link on your post, which will feel even more organic.

We continue to head into a zero-click world on social media, and that second option will likely decline in value too. As time goes on, skipping the links and simply measuring the balance between lift and attribution will continue to be your best bet.

Check out Rand’s video for more.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts

Finding yourself in Search isn’t the same as being discoverable

Reading Time: 2 minutesA few weeks ago, I was talking with a colleague that was trying to sell her marketing services to a new client. She has a…

Read More

What happens when someone replies to your newsletter?

Reading Time: 2 minutesEven with AI and and social media and all of the chaos you can find online, I sincerely hope that you’re still sending out value-packed…

Read More

How to quickly take action from your Analytics

Reading Time: < 1 minuteGiant data reports might look impressive, but reports that get to the point are a lot more effective. We’ve worked hard to make our reports…

Read More