February 5, 2026

Social media outcomes for kids are U-shaped

jama-pediatrics-social-media
Reading Time: 2 minutes

There has been a ton of hang-wringing in recent years about the use of social media among adolescents, but the data doesn’t really match the hysteria.

To be clear, social media isn’t all sunshine and roses, and there are serious concerns to be addressed at every level. However, a flat-out ban on social media for kids is likely to be problematic in other ways.

First, there is the idea of the U-shaped curve. According to a study from JAMA Pediatrics, studying over 100,000 students grade 4-12:

  • Kids who use social media excessively have the worst outcomes.
  • Kids who use social media moderately have the best outcomes.
  • Kids who don’t use social media at all also have the worst outcomes.

Letting kids use social media excessively is a big problem, but so is banning it entirely.

As shared by Techdirt, there was another study by the University of Manchester that followed 25,000 11- to 14-year-olds over three school years, and found social media had literally no impact on their mental health.

“The study found no evidence for boys or girls that heavier social media use or more frequent gaming increased teenagers’ symptoms of anxiety or depression over the following year. Increases in girls’ and boys’ social media use from year 8 to year 9 and from year 9 to year 10 had zero detrimental impact on their mental health the following year.“

As with most things in life, moderation is key. Letting your child run wild on social media is a bad idea, but banning it entirely is proving to be equally problematic. As Techdirt shares, “Cutting kids off entirely doesn’t return them to some idyllic pre-digital social existence. It cuts them off from their actual social world.“

There are no easy answers here, but a flat-out ban is likely to do more harm than good.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts

One post a week or 1,000 posts a day

Reading Time: 2 minutesIf you’re using social media to try to grow your business, I’m increasingly convinced that you should pick one of two directions: Post once a…

Read More

Clips are the main consumption method for the majority of the internet

Reading Time: < 1 minuteAs short-form video continues to explode on the internet, it’s coming at the expense of longer-form video. Most short-form video was taken as a clip…

Read More

1,000 social posts a day

Reading Time: < 1 minuteHow often should your business be posting on social media? Weekly? Twice a week? Daily? Gary Vaynerchuk is famous for his consistently high level of…

Read More