October 15, 2025

Dang, another good human has sold out to AI

mickmel_a_metal_robot_sitting_at_a_desk_talking_on_a_phone_4e12bc80-62d3-499a-8912-72c0a1c5c2be
Reading Time: 2 minutes

I’m becoming increasingly disappointed when great, human-focused companies just sell out completely to AI for their communications. AI can be fantastic for many things, as I often share on here, but using AI to eliminate conversations with your customers just seems so foolish.

My dentist did it a few months ago — AI kept scheduling me at the wrong time (I showed up twice for appointments that they didn’t have on record), and it was literally impossible to get a human on the phone. They did good work, but I had to move on to a different dentist because they left me no choice.

Then we had Hyundai of Kennesaw, who is generally the most human-focused car dealer I’d seen, who has opted to take humans out of the relationship as much as possible. It’s super weird.

Now we have the company that refinanced our house last year. It’s a local company, with a guy that I see around town quite a bit. I like those kinds of relationships, and I thought that was a focus of how they work. It seems I was wrong.

During our recent Brighter Web Conference, I got call from his office that I wasn’t able to take and it went to my voicemail. The transcription of the voicemail popped up on my phone, and included this:

“Hi, this is Mia. I work with (name) at (company). We have some great news. (name) took a look at your loan, and we found a way to save you some money on your mortgage payment.”

Cool! We had discussed making some changes when rates dropped, so that seemed about right. Being at the conference I wasn’t able to return her call, so I texted the number back asking for more info. I never got a response.

When I got home I listened to the actual message and understood why they never replied to my text — “Mia” was clearly an AI voice (it wasn’t even very good), so that’s why they never responded.

Dude, I’m disappointed about this one. I thought this company was just a good local group that was proud of their human touch. Someone apparently convinced them to “gain efficiencies” with AI, and they went all in. Now they’re just the same as the other 5,000 home lenders in the country, and I have no reason to stick with them.

Please make it make sense.

—

Side note: After I had written this post (and after I had already exchanged a few emails with this lender), I received an email “from” this man again a day later which lead with:

I hope this email finds you well!

Rates have come down since we closed your last loan. It might be a good idea for us to reevaluate your current situation and see if we can lower your rate, eliminate mortgage insurance or if there is a cash out opportunity.

Clearly 100% automated, and only served to make him look more foolish and disconnected.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts

The Next Five Blog Posts You Should Write Are Already in Your Inbox

Reading Time: < 1 minuteBlogging is making a bit of a resurgence, though in a very different way that it did the past. If you previously wrote blog posts…

Read More

An automated caller may be asking on behalf of a real customer

Reading Time: < 1 minuteFor years (decades?) now, most businesses have worked hard to block bots. No bots filling out forms, no bots making phone calls, no bots emailing…

Read More

Let AI play the role of a skeptical customer

Reading Time: < 1 minuteThere are lots of great ways to use AI, and one neat thing you can do with AI is to give a role to play….

Read More