October 30, 2025

Notes from “Upstream” by Dan Heath

upstream-dan-heath-book-cover
Reading Time: 4 minutes

“When you spend years responding to problems, you can sometimes overlook the fact that you could be preventing them.”

This is something we’ve all done — worked to find efficient ways to solve a problem instead of working to prevent the problem from occurring in the first place. Dan Heath’s “Upstream” digs into why that happens and how to solve it.

Check out my video overview of the book here, or read on to see some of my notes.

1. Moving Upstream

“When you spend years responding to problems, you can sometimes overlook the fact that you could be preventing them.”

“The effort to reduce call volume at Expedia was a successful upstream intervention. Downstream actions react to problems once they’ve occurred. Upstream efforts aim to prevent those problems from happening.”

“Notice what was missing: It was no group’s job to ensure that customers didn’t need to call for support. In fact, no team really stood to gain if customers stopped calling. It wasn’t what they were measured on.”

  • Reminds me of “Goodhart’s Law”

That’s one reason why we tend to favor reaction: Because it’s more tangible. Downstream work is easier to see. Easier to measure. There is a maddening ambiguity about upstream efforts. One day, there’s a family that does not get into a car accident because a police officer’s presence made them incrementally more cautious. That family has no idea what didn’t happen, and neither does the officer. How do you prove what did not happen? Your only hope, as a police chief, is to keep such good evidence of crashes that you can detect success when the numbers start falling. But even if you feel confident your efforts accomplished something, you’ll still never know who you helped.

In this book, I’m defining upstream efforts as those intended to prevent problems before they happen or, alternatively, to systematically reduce the harm caused by those problems.

Section 1: The Three Barriers to Upstream Thinking

2. Problem Blindness

To succeed upstream, leaders must: detect problems early, target leverage points in complex systems, find reliable ways to measure success, pioneer new ways of working together, and embed their successes into systems to give them permanence.

Above we talked about how habituation can help with phobias by normalizing the problematic. What Lin was doing, with the term sexual harassment, was the opposite: She wanted to problematize the normal.

3. A Lack of Ownership

4. Tunneling

The psychologists Eldar Shafir and Sendhil Mullainathan, in their book “Scarcity”, call this “tunneling”: When people are juggling a lot of problems, they give up trying to solve them all. They adopt tunnel vision. There’s no long-term planning; there’s no strategic prioritization of issues. And that’s why tunneling is the third barrier to upstream thinking—because it confines us to short-term, reactive thinking. In the tunnel, there’s only forward.

“And, by the way, how are her colleagues going to feel about someone who is always yammering on about “fixing processes” rather than simply grabbing more towels from another unit? It’s so much easier—and more natural—to stay in the tunnel and keep digging ahead.”

  • I think the same is true when learning to delegate to others — it’s easier to do it myself.

Section 2: Seven Questions for Upstream Leaders

5. How Will You Unite the Right People?

6. How Will You Change the System?

“On sharp curves where accidents tend to happen, transportation departments have begun to install high friction surface treatments (HFSTs)—overlays of ultra-rough material superglued to existing roads. In Kentucky, where the treatments have been used widely, crashes have been reduced almost 80%. None of those drivers, who avoided crashes they would have suffered in an alternate world, will ever know that they may owe their lives to some construction workers who installed a super-gritty road.”

  • This could also be:
    • COVID vaccines
    • Self-driving cars
    • Many non-profits, like K2L

“The first thing to realize is that if you have a large organization filled with a relatively homogenous population of employees, then that composition did not happen by chance.”

7. Where Can You Find a Point of Leverage?

Upstream leaders should be wary of common sense, which can be a poor substitute for evidence.

“The postmortem for a problem can be the preamble to a solution.”

8. How Will You Get Early Warning of the Problem?

The Safe2Say system (youth violence prevention program in Pennsylvania) will no doubt be prone to overreactions and even cruel pranks. It will almost certainly surface many false positives for every genuine threat avoided. To make matters worse, it’s the curse of preventing rare problems that we may never really know when we’ve succeeded. (How could anyone prove conclusively that the kid in Hazleton would have perpetrated a massacre?)

9. How Will You Know You’re Succeeding?

“There is also a third kind of ghost victory that’s essentially a special case of the second. It occurs when measures become the mission. This is the most destructive form of ghost victory, because it’s possible to ace your measures while undermining your mission.”

“When people’s well-being depends on hitting certain numbers, they get very interested in tilting the odds in their favor.”

10. How Will You Avoid Doing Harm?

“It’s genuinely difficult to buy a poorly made car these days, especially now that the Pontiac Aztek is gone.”

11. Who Will Pay for What Does Not Happen?

A few years ago, my wife and I flipped to “upstream” pest control. We’d had a problem with spiders, so we called an exterminator. When he visited, he offered us a subscription service. The idea was that they’d visit on a regular basis—not requiring an appointment, just spraying outside our home periodically—using the best strategies they’d learned to keep bugs at bay. At first, we were skeptical—“Are we getting ripped off here?”—but ultimately what won us over was the beautiful vision of removing bugs from our life concerns. So we did it, and we removed one small source of drama from our lives.

Section 3: Far Upstream

12. The Chicken Little Problem

Distant and Improbable Threats

“There’s a concept called “the prophet’s dilemma”: a prediction that prevents what it predicts from happening. A self-defeating prediction. What if Chicken Little’s warnings actually stopped the sky from falling? The Y2K bug was an example of the prophet’s dilemma. The warnings that the sky would fall triggered the very actions that kept the sky from falling.

13. You, Upstream

Which problems have you come to accept as inevitable that are, in fact, nothing of the kind? Maybe it’s something small: say, the irritation of finding a place to park in a crowded parking lot. I met a woman who told me about an epiphany: “I literally have a step-counter on my wrist and yet I was driving myself crazy trying to find a close space. It was madness. So now I always park in the most remote spot in the lot. I think of it as a ‘VIP spot,’ away from the other cars. I get some extra steps and don’t stress about finding a spot. It’s such a wonderful sense of relief, like I’ve purged that concern forever from my life.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts

The Sages, by Charles Morris

Reading Time: < 1 minuteI recently read “The Sages” by Charles Morris, which digs into the financial lives and brilliance of three men: Warren Buffett, George Soros, and Paul…

Read More

The Go-Giver, by Bob Burg and John David Mann

Reading Time: 3 minutesNow that I’m using Reading Refresh to keep myself up to date on books I’ve read in the past, I thought I’d share some of…

Read More

The Design of Everyday Things by Don Norman

Reading Time: 2 minutesNow that I’m using Reading Refresh to keep myself up to date on books I’ve read in the past, I thought I’d share some of…

Read More